A hallway with newly laid hardwood flooring running through archways into a dining room

Advice

Making a Flooring Decision: Should I Choose Hardwood Flooring?

In most of the country this is a taste question. In the Lake Houston area it is a water question first, and taste second.

6 minute read

The three options, honestly described

Solid hardwood is a single piece of timber, usually three quarters of an inch thick. It can be sanded and refinished several times over decades, which is its real advantage: it is the only one of the three that you can make new again. It also moves with humidity, and it does not forgive standing water.

Engineered wood is a real hardwood veneer over a plywood core. The core is dimensionally stable, so it handles humidity swings far better than solid timber, and the surface is genuine wood. Depending on the thickness of the veneer it can sometimes be refinished once, sometimes not at all.

Luxury vinyl plank is not wood, and the good ones no longer pretend to be in a way that embarrasses anybody. It is waterproof, it is hard to damage, and it is the only one of the three that does not care if the dishwasher leaks overnight.

What it costs in Houston

Hardwood flooring installed averages $5,066 in Houston, within a typical range of $2,690 to $7,688 (Angi, Houston). Luxury vinyl plank typically runs about $4 to $8 per square foot installed. Engineered wood sits between the two and varies most, because the price is driven by the thickness of the wear layer rather than by the look.

Those ranges overlap enough that price alone rarely decides it. What decides it is usually the next section.

The flood question, which comes first here

Hurricane Harvey flooded more than 16,000 homes and 3,300 businesses in the Lake Houston area, roughly 20% of all homes in it, according to SBA estimates compiled by Reduce Flooding. In some Kingwood neighborhoods it was not one in five: The Enclave flooded 283 of 283 homes.

Then Winter Storm Uri burst pipes in two of every five Harris County homes (University of Houston Hobby School of Public Affairs).

So before anybody talks about colour, we ask two questions. Has this floor been under water before, and is the property in a flood zone. If the answer to either is yes, luxury vinyl plank on the ground floor is very often the right call, and it is not a compromise. It is choosing the material that suits the conditions, which is what specifying a floor actually is.

Plenty of our clients put waterproof plank downstairs and real hardwood upstairs for exactly this reason, and it is a sensible split rather than a half measure.

Slab or pier and beam, which changes the answer again

Most newer houses here sit on a concrete slab. Solid hardwood does not go directly onto a slab without a proper moisture barrier and a subfloor, because concrete holds and releases moisture continuously, and that is exactly what solid timber reacts to. Engineered wood and luxury vinyl plank both handle a slab far more easily.

On pier and beam, with a ventilated crawl space, solid hardwood is much more straightforward.

If a contractor quotes you solid hardwood on a slab without mentioning the moisture barrier, that is worth asking about before you sign anything.

What we would actually recommend

For a ground floor in a flood-affected or flood-zone property: luxury vinyl plank, without hesitation.

For a ground floor on a slab, away from water risk, where you want real wood: engineered, with as thick a wear layer as the budget allows.

For upstairs, or on pier and beam, where you plan to stay for decades: solid hardwood, and enjoy the fact that your grandchildren could sand it back.

In a kitchen specifically, the first question is always what happens the day the dishwasher leaks, because eventually one does. That single question has changed more flooring specifications for us than any showroom sample ever has.

Thinking about this job?

Flooring

Hundreds of flooring options to choose from.

Read the full page

Start here

Start with a free estimate.

A free in-home consultation and a written estimate, with no obligation at the end of it.

  • Rated 4.8 on Google across 32 reviews
  • Renovating North Houston homes since 2005
  • Free in-home consultation, no obligation
(713) 757-2790
Step 1 of 4Project
What would you like to transform?
CallFree estimate